Free Exercise Exceptionalism - St Mary v. Roy
Posted By:
Jeff Oster
Posted On: 2026-11-18T20:12:31Z
St. Mary Parish v. Roy heard before SCOTUS on November 3, 2026 highlights the free exercise exceptionalism demanded by the Catholic Church. The Roberts Court, appearing very interested in reviewing these religious liberty cases, is heavily weighted with Catholic justices (6/9). In this environment, can the individual civil rights of the LGBTQ community stand on equal footing with that of the Catholic Church in St. Mary v. Roy?
Erwin Chemerinsky, Dean of the University of California, Berkeley School of Law recently wrote in SCOTUSblog, a powerful argument entitled, 'Treating the free exercise of religion and equal protection differently. In this article, Mr. Chermerinsky is the first to clearly describe that the half century of protection of civil rights that has now become the victim of the Supreme Court's new and dangerous interpretation of the rights of organized religion. Mr. Chermerinsky clearly puts forth the bold truth; no group, regardless of gender, race or sexual orientation, should be forced to lessor rights than the church.
This article stands firmly behind the logic used by the state of Colorado in crafting the universal pre school program (UPK). St. Mary Parish can chose to participate in the UPK program but it cannot set the terms of their participation and discriminate against the LGBTQ community. Can the Catholic justices see through their implicit prejudices or will they continue to infringe upon the rights of others in support for the myth of religion and in their support for the power of the organized church. Unilateral support of the church will certainly result in a disparate impact.